Nominations questions

[pocketmouse]

Questions that have come up as we're approving nominations:

Fandoms:

Merged the two Vampire Diaries fandoms that were in the set, since one was already the & Related Fandoms tag.


Warcraft (2016): No one's nominated any of the games yet, so I'm inclined to keep this fandom as-is, if anyone is planning to nominate any of the books or games, we can switch this to AMT to put them all together.

Voltron: Legendary Defenders has some relationships nominated with (VLD) as the disambig, others are using (Voltron). I'm assuming VLD is the only Voltron fandom currently being nominated, yes?

Sailor Moon: this has been nominated specifically for the 90's anime - the canonical tag for that fandom also encompasses the manga. Is using that manga + anime canonical tag OK?

Supergirl is part of Arrowverse, yes?

Top Gear UK doesn't differentiate between hosting eras in AO3 so I am merging the two separate fandom nominations.

Please confirm whether any of the Pokemon nominations (main game, Mystery Dungeon, GO) can be merged to a higher-level tag (AMT).

I've got Power Rangers (series) and Power Rangers (2017). Both relationships in (2017) are also present in (series), can the (2017) fandom be struck?

I have American Gods nominated in both Book and TV, with most of the nominations under TV. I'd like to move them all to TV or make an AMT tag (AO3 doesn't seem to have one yet), any objections?

The Expanse has been nominated in both Book and TV, with the same relationship in both (sounds like nominations from two different people, based on comments. Can these be merged under an AMT?

Game of Thrones and ASOIAF were both nominated - all ASOIAF tags overlap with GoT, which has additional relationships. Unless there are objections, I'm going to remove ASOIAF.


Relationships:

American Gods and GOT/ASOIAF are keeping their seperate fandoms, so please confirm whether there are any relationships that need to move/be added to one fandom or the other.

I've got a Harry Potter relationship nomination for "Harry Potter/Tom Riddle/Voldemort." Please clarify.

I think I've struck all the duplicate relationships (inside a given fandom, not duplicates between fandoms), please let me know if you see any!


Angerboda/Loki/Sigyn (Marvel) has been nominated under MCU and not the general Marvel tag. Please confirm where this relationship should be. Relationship has been placed at the top-level Marvel fandom.

Simon Baz/Jessica Cruz/Diana (Wonder Woman) has been nominated under DCU (Comics) and not DC Cinematic Universe. Please confirm where this relationship should be. Relationship has been placed in DCU (Comics).

I've got a couple American Gods/Supernatural relationships that were nominated under the separate fandom(s). I'm assigning them to the Crossover fandom.

Celebrían/Elrond Peredhel/Ereinion Gil-galad is showing up in a couple incorrect Tolkien fandoms, which one should it be under?

Anything in the Buffy and Angel fandoms that should only be in one versus the other? (Or I could create a Buffy & Angel fandom to merge the noms under)

River-Woman (LotR)/Uinen/Tar-Míriel (Silmarillion) has been nominated under Crossover fandom. Is there a Tolkien fandom that would be more appropriate? This might not be the only Tolkien tag with this issue.

Comments

[(Anonymous)]

Not my nominations, but the Power Rangers (series) and Power Rangers (2017) are completely different beasts. None of the characters are interchangeable.

Show Jason - A mature young man that teaches karate classes
Movie Jason - Captain of the football team that hurt his leg and was caught by the police after playing a prank
Show Kimberly - A gymnast that also knows sign language and a passion for gardening
Movie Kimberly - Former cheerleader having an internal dilemma after realizing she's been a bully
Show Trini - An activist martial artist who is able to understand technobabble
Movie Trini - A loner who has moved from place to place so many times that she's always the new girl
Show Zack - Jason's best friend, a martial artist and a dancer who is fun loving
Movie Zack - A young man terrified of the prospect of his mother dying covering it up with a front
Show Billy - A socially awkward genius that is taking karate lessons
Movie Billy - A socially awkward genius that is on the spectrum

Also movie Rita and Zordon are both explicitly former ranger while show Rita and Zordon aren't.

In addition, almost every character is played by an actor of a different ethnicity.

The part of the series where the characters appear is firmly set in the 90s while the movie is set in the 2010s.

[pocketmouse]

Good to know, thanks!